Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence

Nov. 14, 2012, 11:59 p.m.

Stanford University, the American media and the United States government are all complicit in the atrocities that have developed in the Gaza Strip over the past few days.

Yesterday, Nov. 14, Israeli forces fired strikes upon Gaza that have killed at least 15 Palestinians, including seven-year-old Ranan Arafat and 11-month-old Omar Mashrawi. Attacks by the Israeli Defense Forces have wounded at least 100 Palestinians so far.

Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
Ranan Afarat, 7, was killed by Israeli strikes on Gaza on November 14.
Picture c/o Twitter.

Israel is preparing to expand the raid that killed Hamas military leader Ahmed Jabari with air and naval assault yesterday. American media were conspicuously silent on these developments, having waited hours after outlets like Reuters, Russia Today and Al Jazeera English first ran reports on the stikes — and having buried this story deep on their homepages.

The New York Times has misreported the events leading up to the Israeli attack and did not give a single mention to the civilian casualties in its original report, which was released hours after most major outlets had already confirmed such deaths.

The American media has already judged which lives lost are valuable and which ones are not. The Times, which again mentioned nothing about Palestinian civilian deaths in its original reporting, now leads its website with the following paragraph:

Three Israeli civilians were killed on Thursday when a rocket hit an apartment block, the first casualties on Israel’s side, as a ferocious assault against Hamas and other militant groups entered its second day.”

The United States government continues to offer unwavering support to Israel, which the rest of the international community has consistently reprimanded for its violation of international human rights in its occupation of Palestine and acts of collective punishment against Palestinians.

The United States spends $8.5 million in aid every day to support Israel’s military, and Stanford’s endowments — both on the university level and within our ASSU endowment — have not yet divested from companies that profit from Israel’s human rights violations. It is imperative that we do so as this conflict escalates.

All quiet on the Western front

Here is the timeline of events that The New York Times, America’s most esteemed news outlet, failed to report on the backstory leading up to yesterday’s strikes against Gaza.

As stated above, The Times did not mention a single one of the civilian deaths or injuries Palestinians have suffered in the past 24 hours.

Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
Doctor holds a child victim of the Nov. 14 Israeli attacks on Gaza. (c/o

Beyond that, The Times paints Israel’s military aggression as one of response to Palestinian provocation, without noting the series of six preemptive extrajudicial executions Israel has committed in the past week — including the killings of three Palestinian children between Nov. 8 and Nov. 12.

The rockets fired from Gaza in the days preceding Wednesday’s Israeli offensive were in retaliation to Israeli provocation.

Palestinian fire is never contextualized, never in ‘return’ for the cruel, years-long siege that has systematically destroyed Gaza’s economy and subjected an entire generation of Palestinian children to malnutrition-related deficiencies,” reports Palestinian news outlet Electronic Intifada. “Never in ‘return’ for decades of devastating military occupation. Fire from Gaza is never in ‘return’ for the continued dispossession of historic Palestine which made most of the population in Gaza refugees in the first place.”

Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
Relatives of Matar Abu Al-Atta (19), killed the day before by an Israeli military attack, mourn during his funeral in the al-Shoja’iya neighborhood east of Gaza City, Nov. 11, 2012.
(Photo: Anne Paq/

This frame is perpetuated by an American media that has been all but silent on the escalations between Israel and Gaza.

Beyond reporting that Israeli forces killed Hamas military leader Ahmed Jabari on Wednesday, American media was largely silent on the casualties of the attacks. This silence is shocking when compared with international outlets like Russia Today, which has been live blogging updates since 10 a.m. PST on Wednesday.

ReutersThe TelegraphThe Guardian and Al Jazeera all also ran the story as their front-and-center features.

While all of these foreign outlets have been pursuing these developments as their leading stories, American media initially buried the story deep on their homepages. It required zooming out to view the story on the Times’ homepage, CNN and Fox News mentioned the developments as mid-page bullet points, and one had to scroll down three screens on the Wall Street Journal to see a headline about Gaza.

Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
NYT homepage requires zooming out to view information about Israeli attacks on Gaza.

The silence of American media on this very important development for our “biggest ally in the Middle East” is indicative of the moral failure of this country in the context of the Palestine-Israel conflict.

Burying the story ensures that Americans will remain ignorant about the conflict, and ignorant about their role in it. They will not know that more of their aid goes to Israel than all of Africa and Latin America combined each year.

Ignorance ensures that people will not care enough to demand their government stop sponsoring international human rights violations.

Apathy here means supporting an oppressive status quo.

(Read the NYT article for yourself here.)


The IDF has gone as far as to live-tweet the operation, with links to YouTube videos and pictures of the strike on Jabari and the hashtag #pillarofdefense.

Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
Tweet from Israeli Defense Forces on Nov. 14 attacks on Gaza.

We recommend that no Hamas operatives, whether low level or senior leaders, show their faces above ground in the days ahead,” the handle IDFSpokesperson tweeted Wednesday.

Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
IDF spokesperson live-tweeting Nov. 14 attacks on Gaza.

The flippant dehumanization of such a media campaign — conducted for English-speaking audiences — is something we have not seen a nation-state do before and paints a frightening image of what our futures may look like.

Full pledge of support

I wrote last week and again this week about not supporting Barack Obama’s re-election because his foreign policies leave the United States on the wrong side of history. I maintain that United States’ policy is still on the wrong side of history.

We support Israel’s right to defend itself, and we encourage Israel to continue to take every effort to avoid civilian casualties,” the Pentagon wrote today in a press release.

Such a statement is highly concerning in the context of Israel’s history attacking Gaza.

The intensity of today’s attacks are reminiscent of Operation Cast Lead, in which Israeli forces responded to missile strikes by Hamas and other Palestinian factions by killing 1,400 Palestinians in a 22-day raid on the Gaza Strip. Three hundred of these casualties were children, and hundreds were unarmed civilians.

Israel lost 10 soldiers and three civilians during this same period of time.

The U.S. government was similarly silent in response to these 1,400 deaths.

Stanford investments

Stanford has a $17 billion endowment, which it maintains by investment in public equity, private equity, real estate, natural resources and other areas. Stanford also allegedly maintains a commitment to ethical investment, wherein “when the Trustees determine that the corporate policies or practices of a company Stanford may invest in could cause substantial social injury they, as responsible and ethical investors, shall give independent weight to this factor in determining Investment Responsibility Policies and Proxy Voting Guidelines for corporate securities.”

Our University endowment and our ASSU endowment each likely invest in companies that profit off of human rights violations in Palestine-Israel.

The most relevant company to the current conflict in Gaza is Lockheed Martin, which “supplies the Israeli military with AGM-114 Hellfire Missiles and F-16s, both routinely used to bomb Palestinian homes and kill innocent civilians in acts of collective punishment,” according to Students for Palestinian Equal Rights. “It stands as the single biggest overseas supplier for the Israeli armaments industry, having received at least $4.4 billion since 1995 for supplying missile systems and fighter planes to Israel.

Given that Lockheed Martin is number 58 on the 2012 Fortune 500 list and participates in Stanford’s Career Fair, it is safe to assume that at least some part of our $17 billion goes toward this company that is directly implicated in this week’s violence in Gaza.

It is the University’s ethical responsibility to disinvest itself (divest) from this international conflict.

Speak up!

Today we sent a clear message to Hamas and other terrorist organizations, and if it becomes necessary we are prepared to expand the operation,” Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Wednesday.

What message is clear is that silence on the American media’s part — and strong support from the American government — seems to give Israeli forces the go-ahead for a similarly catastrophic attack.

Unless the world speaks up.

We play a role in this conflict as students, and I encourage you, Stanford, to get educated and not to be apathetic.

We need to speak up.

The Palestinians are a people occupied and oppressed by one of the most powerful militaries in the world, with billions of dollars in aid each year from the largest military force in the world. In Gaza, Israel has control over all borders — land, sea and air — and therefore can limit access to the outside world, including access to food and medicine.

Stanford, we must do our part by demanding that the University divest from these conflicts, spreading this information and protesting at the Israeli consulate in San Francisco on Friday. We. Must. Do. Something.

To close this piece, I present a series of  information about the grossly unbalanced power structures in operation in the Israeli occupation of Palestine.

Consider the following:

Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
Palestinian & Israeli Injuries and Casualties since 2001. Statistics last updated on April 25, 2012. C/o


Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
Palestinian & Israeli U.S. aid, political prisoners and demolished homes since 2001. Statistics last updated on April 25, 2012. c/o



Stanford, we are complicit in Gaza violence
c/o Visualizing Palestine.
Last updated April 25, 2012.




Kristian Davis Bailey is a junior studying Comparative Studies in Race & Ethnicity. A full time journalist/writer and occasional student, he's served as an Opinion section editor, News writer and desk editor for The Daily, is a community liaison for Stanford STATIC, the campus' progressive blog and journal, and maintains his own website, 'With a K.' He's interested in how the press perpetuates systems of oppression and seeks to use journalism as a tool for dismantling such systems.

Login or create an account

Apply to The Daily’s High School Summer Program

Priority deadline is april 14