Heading back to my apartment to open my Caltech transfer decision, I kept on the bravest face I could. My friend was telling me about his latest mathematical research, which I nodded along to, trying to hide my nausea. An hour earlier, I had made the mistake of glancing at my phone during quantum mechanics recitation and spotted the minuscule notification:
“Your Caltech application for admission has a status update”
Memories of getting my high school rejections — still sore — immediately returned, not to mention my Berkeley transfer rejection just a few weeks prior. The derivation on the board no longer mattered to me much, but I tried my best to keep pace. On my laptop, sitting on the couch at my apartment, a familiar scene unfolded. A hesitant click, a moment of disbelief, then a celebration as I realized I had gotten into Caltech.
I remember the first thing I thought when I saw the little beavers fall across the screen was that my life was about to change a lot. The transfer exam was hard, sure, but the statistics were harder to beat. I was amazed that, out of hundreds of applications, they wanted me. The next month was a blur as I planned my visit to an institution whose rejection I had once cried over.
The first thing I remember was the awe of realizing that the land I stood on could be my home. I explored the arcades of the institute, my camera and I trying and struggling to grasp the culture of the institution. Through the day, I met with students and faculty, exploring the labs and trying to imagine what my life as a Caltech student would look like.
This day in particular was the day that Canvas was hacked, much to the frustration of the students at Red Door Cafe complaining about their p-set due dates and NMR analytes. I once again made the mistake, however, of looking down at my phone and opening my Gmail:
“Your Stanford Application”
Oh, just great. Of all places to get that email. Hours of anxiety passed before I could limp back to my hotel to once again live out a scene so many high school students dream of. I didn’t really feel joy at getting into Stanford. I was shocked, but was more disoriented by the decision I now had to make, and the prospect of considering a school whose campus I had never once set foot on.
I spoke to so many alumni in the following weeks, of varying relationships to Stanford and Caltech, from a Caltech undergraduate turned Stanford graduate student to full-time engineers with only a bachelor’s degree. The stories I was told differed from the ones the students told me. They said of Stanford that their only regrets were not staying longer, but their pictures of Caltech were much less flattering. Among its many strengths, they fretted about the performatively difficult workload and a culture that you either fit into perfectly or fell out of badly.
Stanford was hard, too, but as the former Caltech undergraduate pointed out, it was hard because it is a triathlon, not because it is a sprint. At Stanford, you have club meetings, artistic performances, problem sets and midterms on a daily basis in a never-ending, frenetic tangle. At Caltech, as one faculty member remarked to me, many are primarily focused on coursework during the school year, leaving the summer and breaks for the miscellanea.
Each college in California caters to a different kind of student, from the most creative to the intensely practical, but Caltech lies at extremes of the axes. Caltech demanded a certain type of person that I wasn’t. It demanded a specialist, someone so dedicated to their passion that they would sacrifice the luxuries other colleges provide for the chance to immerse themselves wholly.
I could imagine my life at most of the schools of California — the artistic, industrial or academic endeavors they would lead me towards — but I could not imagine my life after Caltech. I realized that the person Caltech demands was the person I wanted to be, but not the person I would ever be.
As the deadline to commit approached, my unease grew. I knew how big of a name Caltech is in physics, but how could I turn down Stanford? On the other hand, how could I turn down Caltech? Could I force myself to become Caltech’s type, and would that be good for me? I felt so incredibly torn, landing on a different answer each day as the people around me posited their widely varying opinions on the “obvious choice”.
I visited Stanford before making my decision, and I remember remarking to my parents how much more I was able to learn about Stanford from a few hours on its campus compared to the days I spent at Caltech. Stanford felt like an open book to me, whereas Caltech’s world was held firmly behind the locked doors of its houses. I knew what I needed to do, but it took me a few more days to get up the courage to say it to them:
“I really wish that I could have attended Caltech. If I had my wish, I would split myself in half and send one half to Stanford and the other half to Caltech. […], and by the end [of the decision-making process], it just came down to what I need in my life right now. There isn’t anything Caltech could or could not have done to make this a different outcome, and as much as I am heartbroken by the understanding that I will never be an undergraduate at such a wonderful institution, I hope that in graduate school or in another life we can get to know each other. […] I am glad that I got to experience getting into such an institution in my lifetime, and I will always wonder what my life would have been like if I had chosen Caltech.”