Stanford’s silence: Screen or shield?

Opinion by Neelan Krishna
Published Nov. 17, 2026, 2:37 a.m., last updated Nov. 17, 2026, 2:37 a.m.

Last year, I was a student at The University of Texas at Austin (UT), double-majoring in Electrical and Computer Engineering and Plan II, the liberal arts honors program. My classes took me back and forth across Speedway, the pedestrian spine that separates the engineering departments from the College of Liberal Arts. The walk from the engineering side felt like a trip to what the university had effectively labeled the wrong side of the tracks.

The engineers were ebullient about semiconductor research grants the state was eagerly eyeing. The state wants chips, and chips do not offend you with uncomfortable ideas. Meanwhile, the liberal arts side was being shrunk to make it as inoffensive as possible.

In April 2026, according to KUT News, then-interim Dean David Sosa told faculty that seven departments, including African and African Diaspora Studies, Mexican American and Latina/o Studies and Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies, would be consolidated into two before the Texas Legislature reconvenes in early 2027. 

Now, I’m a sophomore transfer at Stanford, where people joke about the techie-and-fuzzy divide. It’s no joke at UT; your side of the divide determines your worth to the university. 

In October 2025, the Trump administration chose nine universities to receive the “Compact for Academic Excellence in Higher Education,” which promised preferential federal funding in exchange for commitments to, among other things, defining sex by reproductive function, capping international enrollment and ensuring faculty exhibited the right ideological mix. MIT rejected it almost immediately, followed by six others. UT Austin maintained an official silence, although the chair of its board of regents called it an honor to be selected. Stanford was not one of the nine. 

On Aug. 3, 2026, the administration tried again, casting a wider net with what is being called ‘Compact 2.0.’ Education Secretary Linda McMahon released a “National Call to Action” that asks every university to voluntarily publish a statement before the end of 2026, detailing adopted and planned reforms related to admissions transparency, free speech, intellectual pluralism, affordability, academic rigor in the age of AI, research security and “American interests.”

On the surface, 2.0 offers neither a carrot nor a stick. However, it suggests that some academic departments have become politicized, and one question asks how faculty hiring will ensure “all relevant perspectives are taken seriously.” The new compact comes against the backdrop of a pending federal rule that would allow research grants not aligned with the president’s priorities to be cut.

UT’s official silence on Compact 1.0 gave critics no statements to pounce on. Instead, the silence acted as a screen for subsequent changes, making it difficult to discern whether UT was complying with parts of the compact. Stanford has not responded to 2.0, although it has been invited to answer in its own words. 

George Porteous, Editor-in-Chief of The Daily, argued in The Harvard Independent that Stanford’s strategy of silence has worked while Harvard, Columbia and Brown have attracted funding freezes. President Jonathan Levin reportedly prefers behind-the-scenes lobbying over open criticism of the Trump administration.

The university’s research already aligns with the administration’s technological priorities in AI, defense research and the chips it helped pioneer. Stanford also scrubbed DEI web pages and closed the Office for Inclusion, Belonging and Intergroup Communication (IBIC) in 2025. Although Levin argued that the Supreme Court’s 2023 affirmative action ruling, rather than pressure from the administration, drove it, the timing seems suspect. 

In 2023, Texas Senate Bill 17 (SB 17) eliminated diversity offices at public universities. SB 37, passed in 2025, replaced UT’s elected Faculty Council with advisory groups appointed by the president, who answers to a politically appointed board.

Washington has picked up this playbook. In 2025, the National Institutes of Health terminated nearly 2,500 research grants, including hundreds focused on the health of women and minority populations. Some of the terminated grants may have deserved scrutiny. But the problem is the capriciousness and the assumption that elected officials or political appointees get to decide what is taught or researched. 

In 1925, the Scopes Monkey Trial saw John Scopes convicted in Tennessee for teaching evolution. He violated the Butler Act, which applied to all public schools and universities, and the legislature passed it to protect Tennesseans from the ideas of distant elites. It was finally repealed in 1967. 

The Butler Act, Compact 1.0, and Compact 2.0 pursue the same goal in increasing order of subtlety. While the Butler Act outlawed a single named idea, the compacts are not that explicit. Their common underlying premise is that whoever is in power should control the curriculum.

In Texas, defenders of SB 17 and SB 37 argue that, as elected representatives of the people, the legislature controls public universities on behalf of taxpayers. By this logic, one can envision a future Democratic legislature that bans the teaching of free-market economics or another Republican one that bans any discussion of Reconstruction. This principle cannot survive a single change of hands at the statehouse.

Stanford’s status as a private university does not put it completely out of Washington’s reach. Over 70% of its research awards are sponsored by the federal government. Stanford has managed to keep Washington on what I would call the engineering side of Speedway, while deflecting the spotlight away from its humanities departments. Stanford’s curricula can sit within a moat only as long as the university can lie low or resist the government that funds most of its research labs. 

For Levin, I think that not taking a public stance on Compact 1.0 was a matter of principle, not expedience. He states that a university’s purpose is learning, not political action. However, answering Compact 2.0’s question on academic rigor in the age of AI is not political. It is a statement of the university’s purpose.

Some have argued that the compact does not merit a response. I saw at UT, though, that institutional silence can let someone in power fill the silence with “your” answer. When you are one of thousands of universities that have been sent the same letter, treating it as junk mail seems like an easy choice. The choice will be more difficult if Stanford is singled out. A statement made now, on Stanford’s terms, will be easier to defend than one, possibly extracted, later. 

Stanford should not stay silent and let the Compact 2.0 deadline pass. The question of academic rigor in the age of AI gives Stanford an opening. At UT Austin and at Stanford, my peers and I frequently use AI tools to automate coding projects. What matters now is for students to learn to sift through uncomfortable information and think for themselves, even, and especially, when their conclusions disagree with the machines. The humanities teach this best when those teaching control the curriculum. 

Stanford’s response should unequivocally commit to keeping decisions on syllabi, departments and majors with the Faculty Senate and departments, not ceding them to or sharing them with federal officials, political appointees, or trustees under political pressure. Texas snatched that away from UT’s faculty. Stanford’s faculty still have it, and explicitly stating this today will make it harder to modify later.

What is taught and researched should come only from the marketplace of ideas. A university cannot train independent thinkers if the syllabus changes with every election. Such an answer makes a public case for the humanities before anyone marks them for diminishment. 

I used to walk between my two intellectual homes when I crossed Speedway at UT Austin—one being rewarded for its usefulness and the other punished for its existence. Now I walk between two quads that Stanford has not had to choose between.

Stanford has until the end of the year to decide whether to continue to stay silent. If its silence is an effective shield, the humanities will never notice it. If it becomes a screen, they’ll be the first to find out.



Login or create an account