‘Brighter days are ahead’: Rachel Maddow ’93 says DOJ can be rebuilt at book talk

Multimedia by Chloe Loquet
Published Nov. 20, 2026, 2:28 a.m., last updated Nov. 20, 2026, 2:29 a.m.

Addressing a sold-out crowd of over 2,000 attendees at Golden Gate Theater on Sunday, Rachel Maddow ’93 said, “I believe that brighter days are ahead, and I’m very happy to be home in the Bay Area.” 

Organized by ATG San Francisco and Book Passage, “Rachel Maddow: A Conversation about ‘Department of Fate,’” put the Castro Valley native and MS NOW host in conversation with tech journalist and podcast host Kara Swisher. At the discussion’s center was Maddow’s new book, “Department of Fate: The Promise, the Power, and the Collapse of America’s Most Consequential Institution.” 

By profiling individuals within the Department of Justice (DOJ), “Department of Fate” delves into the history of the DOJ and how it can inform the rebuilding of the institution.

Maddow opined that while the Justice Department is currently a shell of itself, Congress has a rare chance to rebuild it in the wake of the midterm elections — which, in what the internet has dubbed a “blue-nami,” resulted in the Democrats taking control of the legislature. 

The rain-soaked crowd erupted into a standing ovation the moment the Emmy-winning journalist stepped onto the stage. Maddow opened her talk by reading from “Department of Fate.” The excerpt examined the role of the DOJ in the 1920s Teapot Dome Scandal, a bribery scandal under President Warren Harding that resulted in the resignation of multiple cabinet officials, including U.S. Attorney General Harry Daugherty. 

Maddow invited Swisher on stage for a discussion on the work’s historical and contemporary exploration of the Justice Department. She introduced Swisher as “my friend, my short king doppelgänger, the fun-sized Rachel Maddow, the queen of all media, the woman we will all be working for someday.” 

It was just the first example of the duo’s humorous banter, which, as audience members noted, complemented the evening’s otherwise serious subject matter. 

“[I] found it impressive [that] Maddow could simultaneously joke about butch lesbian haircuts and gay flight attendants alongside such rigorous investigative journalism,” said attendee Armaan Shaarma ’29. 

Mary Welch, an audience member and a frequent viewer of Maddow, praised Maddow and Swisher’s dynamic delivery of both comedy and insight. 

“The two of them together worked really well,” Welch said, noting their rapport was “a nice way to introduce the material.” 

According to Maddow, “Department of Fate” argues that the Justice Department has always been defined by the people who run it: “The sort of meta-thesis of the book is that it really matters who’s there,” she said. 

Among the individuals Maddow profiled was Richard Olney, attorney general under President Grover Cleveland. In the 1890s, Olney weaponized the Sherman Antitrust Act against railroad workers, rather than the very corporations it was meant to restrain. From Maddow’s perspective, his choices reflect how the department and its leaders possess immense power in shaping “the economic course of the nation and the political course of the nation.” 

At the same time, Maddow illustrated how power can also be used for positive change. As an example, she cited Amos Akerman, who — as attorney general under President Ulysses S. Grant — made it the DOJ’s first priority to break the Ku Klux Klan. 

“Nobody remembers him today, but I’m trying desperately to make him famous,” she said. 

In a blunt appraisal of the current DOJ, Maddow admitted she misjudged how the Trump administration would handle the department at the beginning of his first term. She had expected the administration to “supersize” the DOJ into “a nuclear weapon”; instead, she watched it turn into something  closer to “a defective firework, or a broken gun.”

Maddow argued that the dismissal of senior officials, division heads and prosecutors — along with the elimination of entire divisions — has turned the DOJ into “a husk of what it was even two years ago.” Further emphasizing the influence of individuals in shaping the fate of the institution, Maddow noted that during Trump’s first term, U.S. Attorney General William Barr “turned the power of the Justice department inward to destroy it” and inflicted “fatal wounds” on the Department.

She closed by affirming that the U.S. needs a DOJ willing to protect its constitutional republic. 

Reading from her book’s epilogue, Maddow expressed hope that the DOJ “‘can be re-founded and reestablished in a way that not only stands it back up, but stands it back up in a way that allows what just happened to it to never happen again.’” 

“And we don’t need to wait for some faraway constitutional convention or Second American Revolution to do it,” she said. Maddow left the audience with a message of encouragement: The reconstruction and reform of the DOJ is “doable” and “can be set in motion by this Congress and signed into law in January 2029.”



Login or create an account