In Effort to Be Effortlessly Cool: The modern search for identity

Multimedia by Aristaa Bhardwaj
Published Nov. 15, 2026, 10:39 p.m., last updated Nov. 15, 2026, 10:39 p.m.

In her column “In Effort to Be Effortlessly Cool,” Kaitlyn Fan ’30 explores the modern desire to develop “unique,” rather than genuine, interests. She argues that when living our life for others, especially on the internet, our own identities slowly become eroded.

Somewhere between my jumble of Pinterest boards and saved TikToks lies my cobbled-together formula for becoming  a “cool girl.” Countless hours scrolling through queries worthy of sending my ancestors into a stroke — “niche fall style inspiration” and “chic cool interests,” to name a few — have given me the exact playbook. 

I’ll wear sneakers that have just the right amount of vintage flair, paired with oval-shaped glasses as the perfect accessory (who needs contacts anyway!). Pilates is too mainstream of a hobby, but woodworking is way too performative, so I’ll need to find another pastime that falls somewhere in between. I’ll strike the perfect Goldilocks balance between taking care of myself and “not caring” how I’m presented.

In other words, I’ll be the effortlessly cool girl, where my painstakingly curated identity is anything but natural. But by the time I’ve revamped myself, I’ll reload my explore feed, discover that the formula’s shifted and fall behind again.

These endless, microtrend-driven personas often aren’t a curation of my own taste: they’re amalgamations of who I should be. With the rise of influencer marketing and ultra-fast fashion, we’ve learned to relentlessly consume and consume in hopes that these material pursuits will help us form a cohesive sense of self and bring us a sense of purpose. Afraid of the difficult but necessary introspection that developing true values and passions demands, we often fall back on material pursuits as a substitute for personality instead. In doing so, we lose the beauty of authentically growing into ourselves.

From “downtown girl” to “Scandinavian design” to “rockstar girlfriend,” subscribing to an aesthetic promises a complete package of individuality — except it lacks what truly makes someone an individual. There’s something ironic about a TikTok prescribing the “unique shoes you need for 2026” with 300,000 likes: by molding ourselves to what online gurus deem “niche,” our attempts to be unique counterproductively merge into one collective identity. 

This isn’t a sign to not consume any media, but rather, to meaningfully and intentionally consume it. Don’t buy those ballet flats because a TikTok slideshow told you it’s the “what the cool girls are wearing this fall” — buy them because they excite you and expand your personal style. Absorb the boundless creativity these communities foster, but bridge it with your own intentional reflection.  

The obsession with becoming effortlessly cool comes with an implicit shame in enjoying anything mainstream. Recently, I caught myself deleting songs from my Spotify profile and making playlists private because they were “too popular,” as if the more people who enjoyed a piece of art, the less I was allowed to savor it.

But it doesn’t matter whether “About You” by The 1975 has over 1 billion streams or none — that shouldn’t deter me, or anyone, from appreciating the heaven-sent instrumentals each time. Our interests shouldn’t be reduced to status symbols, the constant illusion that popular entertainment is interchangeable with mediocrity. 

What songs would you put on a playlist no one can see? What outfit would you wear if you knew you’d bump into nobody? And most importantly: how would you choose to exist if no one was witness to your life?

That’s a question no for-you-page can answer for you.

Kaitlyn Fan '30 is a columnist at The Grind studying mathematics and computer science. When she's not solving problems or writing, she loves a solid “would you rather”, finding movies to cry to, perfecting her In-N-Out order, and screaming 2010s pop hits. Reach her at kaitlynf 'at' stanford.edu.

Login or create an account