Editor’s Note: This article is a review and contains subjective thoughts, opinions and critiques.
In director Payal Kapadia’s fictional feature film “All We Imagine as Light” (2024), a cast of unseen narrators welcome us to Mumbai. In Gujarati, Bhojpuri and Bengali, various speakers describe the megacity as a place of labor and lost time, a refuge for the heartbroken and a space one can inhabit but never call home.
Indeed, these are the issues the working-class women struggle with throughout the film. “All We Imagine as Light” is a profound, multigenerational story of friendship and a study in how we all possess secrets. Keeping our thoughts and desires hidden, Kapadia contends, is energizing and depleting all at once.
Before we see the compound effects of secrecy, we are first shown how they can provide a distraction from the monotony of work. Prabha (Kani Kusruti) and Anu (Divya Prabha) are flatmates and nurses in a city hospital in Mumbai. Both women are depicted as effective caregivers preoccupied with personal matters. Prabha, the elder of the two, is estranged from her husband and channels her energy into helping her friend Pavarty (Chhaya Kadam), a hospital cook who is being evicted from her tenement. Anu, too, is a strategist: She is in a secret relationship with Shiaz (Hridhu Haroon), a Muslim man whom her family would reject.
As rumors about Anu’s forbidden lover begin to circulate, Prabha must decide whether to confront Anu — and the ways her own judgment has been clouded by loneliness. During a late-night conversation with Anu, Prabha explains that her husband took a job in Europe. The physical distance morphed into emotional distance and eventually silence. Prabha’s occupation puts her into constant contact with patients and trainees, but her spirits only lift ever so slightly around Dr. Manoj (Azees Nedumangad), a colleague who always seeks her out to offer a token of affection or a kind word. Considering her messy feelings, Prabha is understandably constrained in terms of how to address Anu’s relationship.
Kapadia’s script also pays attention to the sociopolitical contours that shape life in Mumbai. Take, for example, the billboard advertising the luxury housing development that will displace Parvaty. Under a smiling fair-skinned family of four, it boasts “Class is a privilege; reserved for the privilege.” Kapadia displays these injustices and has her characters chafe against them: With Prahba’s help, Parvaty consults with a housing attorney and becomes involved in organizing efforts. Vandalizing the billboard in an act of civil disobedience provides the most immediate benefits.
Yet Kapadia attends to the beauty of everyday life despite its stressors. Anu and Shiaz’s scenes show the depth of their infatuation. In a voice message, Anu sends him “kisses through the clouds so when it rains, my kisses will touch your lips.” When one of their secret rendezvous is interrupted by sudden rainfall, the lovers give each other a knowing look. What else is a downpour except being covered in kisses?
The lush visuals of the film are punctuated by composer Topshe’s jaunty piano melody. The score alternately highlights and interrupts the din of urban life and the sound of insects trilling in the night.
Praise should go to the main actresses, who give some of the most extraordinary performances I have seen. As Anu, Divya Prabha’s initial posture of assertive femininity makes her anxiety and fears about the future heartwrenching. Kusruti masterfully holds tension in her body, especially in her hands to showcase how Prabha’s thoughts are elsewhere. Parvaty, a widow, insists that she and Prabha are better off being alone; Kadam delivers this line with an edge of defiance in her voice while Kusruti’s downcast eyes convey an emphatic yet silent non-verbal disagreement.
The generation gaps between the women are especially salient, as they look to each other as portals to destinations their lives may take them. Will Anu end up in a strained arranged marriage like Prabha? Will Prabha embrace being better off alone but possibly displaced? Their stories converge in the final act after Anu is recruited to help Parvaty travel back to her village. It is a testament to Kapadia’s talent as a filmmaker and storyteller that an otherwise sad film ends on a believably hopeful note: After saving a man from drowning, Prahba confronts the impact of her husband’s abandonment, which has been devastating but not insurmountable.
Several key moments take place at night or in the dark, including the final scene. The film ends with a gesture — embracing the present moment without worrying about the past or future. When there is no light, one can choose to let their eyes adjust and rely on other senses.